‘Waiting to die’: the dirty business of recycling in Vietnam

Crouched between mountains of discarded plastic, Lanh strips the labels off bottles of Coke, Evian and local Vietnamese tea drinks so they can be melted into tiny pellets for reuse.More waste arrives daily, piling up like technicolour snowdrifts along the roads and rivers of Xa Cau, one of hundreds of “craft” recycling villages encircling Vietnam’s capital Hanoi where waste is sorted, shredded and melted.The villages present a paradox: they enable reuse of some of the 1.8 million tonnes of plastic waste Vietnam produces each year, and allow employees to earn much-needed wages.But recycling is done with few regulations, pollutes the environment and threatens the health of those involved, both workers and experts told AFP.”This job is extremely dirty. The environmental pollution is really severe,” said Lanh, 64, who asked to be identified only by her first name for fear of losing her job.It is a conundrum facing many fast-growing economies, where plastic use and disposal has outpaced the government’s ability to collect, sort and recycle.Even in wealthy countries, recycling rates are often abysmal because plastic products can be expensive to repurpose and sorting rates are low.But the rudimentary methods used in Vietnam’s craft villages produce dangerous emissions and expose workers to toxic chemicals, experts say.”Air pollution control is zero in such facilities,” said Hoang Thanh Vinh, an analyst at the United Nations Development Programme focused on waste recycling.Untreated wastewater is often dumped directly into waterways, he added.The true scale of the problem is hard to judge, with few comprehensive studies.In one village, Minh Khai, Vinh said a sediment analysis found “very high contamination of lead and the presence of dioxins”, as well as furan — all of which have been linked to cancer.And in 2008, the life expectancy for residents of the villages was found to be a full decade shorter than the national average, according to the environment ministry.Local authorities and the environment ministry did not reply to AFP’s requests for comment.Lanh believes the toxic waste in Xa Cau gave her husband blood cancer, but she still spends her days sorting rubbish to pay his medical bills.”This village is full of cancer cases, people just waiting to die,” she said.- Sickness and wealth -No data exists on cancer rates in the villages, but AFP spoke to more than half a dozen workers in Xa Cau and Minh Khai who reported colleagues or family members with cancer.Xuan Quach, coordinator of the Vietnam Zero Waste Alliance, said sustained exposure to the “toxic environment” made it inevitable that residents face “health risks that are of course higher”.Dat, 60, has been sorting plastic in Xa Cau for a decade and said the job “definitely affects your health”.  “There’s no shortage of cancer cases in this village.”But there is also no shortage of workers, keen for the economic lifeline recycling provides.In Xa Cau, plastic piles up around multi-storey homes, some with ornate facades noting the years they were built.”We get richer thanks to this business,” said 58-year-old Nguyen Thi Tuyen, who lives in a two-storey home.”Now all the houses are brick houses… In the past, we were just a farming village.” Most of the waste the villagers recycle is home-grown, researchers and residents say.But even though Vietnam only recycles about a third of its own plastic waste, it also imports thousands of tons annually from Europe, the United States and Asia.Imports soared after China stopped accepting plastic waste in 2018, though recently Vietnam has tightened regulations and announced plans to phase out imports too.For now, US and EU trade statistics show shipments to Vietnam from the two economies reached over 200,000 tonnes last year.In Minh Khai, the owner of a plant producing plastic pellets said domestic supply “is not enough”.”I have to import from overseas,” 23-year-old Dinh, who only gave one name, explained over the whir of heavy machinery. Most domestic waste doesn’t get sorted, so it cannot easily be reused. There have been efforts to improve the industry, including a ban on burning unrecyclable waste and building modern facilities.But burning continues and unusable waste is often dumped in empty lots, according to Vinh.He said the government should help recyclers move to industrial parks with better environmental safeguards, formalising a sector that handles a quarter of the country’s recycling.”The current way of recycling in recycling villages… is not good to the environment at all.”

Famed Jerusalem stone still sells despite West Bank economic woes

Despite the catastrophic state of the Palestinian economy, Faraj al-Atrash, operator of a quarry in the occupied West Bank, proudly points to an armada of machines busy eating away at sheer walls of dusty white rock that stretch into the distance.”This here is considered the main source of revenue for the entire region”, Atrash said at the site near the town of Beit Fajjar, close to the city of Hebron.The quarry is a source of Jerusalem stone, the famed pale rock used throughout the Holy Land and beyond for millennia and which gives much of the region its distinctive architectural look. But Atrash, in his fifties, said “our livelihood is constantly under threat”.”Lately, I feel like the occupation (Israel) has begun to fight us on the economic front,” he said.Atrash fears the confiscation of the quarry’s industrial equipment, the expansion of Israeli settlements and the Palestinian financial crisis.The war in Gaza, triggered by Hamas’s October 2023 attack on Israel, dealt a severe blow to a Palestinian economy that was already in poor shape.The Palestinian territories are “currently going through the most severe economic crisis ever recorded,” according to a report by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development presented in late November.Israel, which has occupied the West Bank since 1967, has recently set up hundreds of new checkpoints across the territory, paralysing commercial transport.Beyond restrictions on freedom of movement, a halt in permits for West Bank Palestinians seeking work inside Israel has also had a severe impact.- Soaring costs -“There are problems with exports and market access because we used to export most of the stone to Israel, and after October 7, we ran into difficulties,” explained Ibrahim Jaradat, whose family has owned a quarry for more than 40 years near Sair, also near Hebron.The Palestinian Authority, which exercises partial civilian control over some of the West Bank, is on the brink of bankruptcy.Public services are functioning worse than ever, Atrash said, adding that fixed costs such as water and electricity had soared.Quarries account for 4.5 percent of Palestinian GDP and employ nearly 20,000 workers, according to the Hebron Chamber of Commerce.Around 65 percent of exports are destined for the Israeli market, where some municipalities mandate the use of Jerusalem stone.”The people who buy the stones from us to resell them to construction sites are mostly Israelis,” said Abu Walid Riyad Gaith, a 65-year-old quarry operator.He lamented what he said was a lack of solidarity from Arab countries, which he said do not buy enough of the rock.- ‘Afraid to build’ -Other threats hang over the industry.Most of the roughly 300 quarries in the West Bank are located in Area C, land which falls under full Israeli authority and covers the vast majority of its settlements.”Many (Israeli) settlers pass through here, and if Israel annexes Palestine, it will start with these areas,” said one operator, speaking on condition of anonymity.Some members of Israel’s government, one of the most right-wing in the country’s history, openly discuss plans to annex parts or all of the West Bank.Israeli settlements in the West Bank are illegal under international law.They are expanding at the fastest rate since at least 2017, when the United Nations began tracking such data, according to a recent report by the UN chief. The physical demands of working in a quarry are intense, but for many Palestinians there are few other options as the West Bank’s economy wilts.”We are working ourselves to death,” Atrash said, pointing to his ten labourers moving back and forth in monumental pits where clouds of dust coat them in a white film.In the neighbouring quarry, blinking and coughing as he struggled with the intense work was a former geography teacher. With the Palestinian Authority’s budget crisis meaning he was no longer receiving his salary, he had looked for work in the only local place still hiring.All the labourers AFP spoke to said they suffered from back, eye and throat problems.”We call it white gold,” said Laith Derriyeh, employed by a stonemason, “because it normally brings in substantial amounts of money”.”But today everything is complicated; it’s very difficult to think about the future.””People have no money, and those who do are afraid to build,” he added. 

Trump sues BBC for $10 billion over documentary speech edit

US President Donald Trump on Monday filed a lawsuit seeking at least $10 billion from the BBC over a documentary that edited his 2021 speech to supporters ahead of the US Capitol riot.The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Miami, seeks “damages in an amount not less than $5,000,000,000” for each of two counts against the British broadcaster, for alleged defamation and violation of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act.Trump, 79, had said earlier on Monday that the lawsuit was imminent, claiming the BBC had “put words in my mouth,” even positing that “they used AI or something.”The documentary at issue aired last year before the 2024 election, on the BBC’s “Panorama” flagship current affairs program.The video spliced together two separate sections of Trump’s speech on January 6, 2021 in a way that made it appear he explicitly urged supporters to attack the Capitol, where lawmakers were certifying Joe Biden’s 2020 election win.”The formerly respected and now disgraced BBC defamed President Trump by intentionally, maliciously, and deceptively doctoring his speech in a brazen attempt to interfere in the 2024 Presidential Election,” a spokesperson for Trump’s legal team said in a statement to AFP.”The BBC has a long pattern of deceiving its audience in coverage of President Trump, all in service of its own leftist political agenda,” the statement added. The British Broadcasting Corporation, whose audience extends well beyond the United Kingdom, faced a period of turmoil last month after a media report brought renewed attention to the edited clip.The scandal led the BBC director-general and the organization’s top news executive to resign.Trump’s lawsuit accuses the edited speech in the documentary of being “fabricated and aired by the Defendants one week before the 2024 Presidential Election in a brazen attempt to interfere in and influence the Election’s outcome to President Trump’s detriment.”The BBC has denied Trump’s claims of legal defamation, though BBC chairman Samir Shah has sent Trump a letter of apology.Shah also told a UK parliamentary committee last month that the broadcaster should have acted sooner to acknowledge its mistake after the error was disclosed in a memo, which was leaked to The Daily Telegraph newspaper.The BBC lawsuit is the latest in a string of legal action Trump has taken against media companies in recent years, several of which have led to multi-million-dollar settlements.